blog

In the construction and engineering sectors, one of the most common questions is whether to choose or offer a contract role or a permanent position. Both options are widely available across the industry, and each comes with its own advantages and challenges.

For jobseekers, the decision often comes down to lifestyle, financial goals, and long-term career progression. For employers, it’s about building the right workforce strategy, deciding when to bring in contractors for flexibility and specialist skills vs investing in permanent hires for stability and knowledge retention.

In this blog, we’ve put together 7 key questions to help candidates decide between permanent and contract jobs and to help employers determine when contract or permanent employees are the best fit for their business.

Before comparing roles, ask yourself what matters most to you right now:

• Job security

• Flexibility (hours, location, breaks)

• Long-term career progression and mentorship

• Ability to relocate or travel

• Type of projects you want to work on

• Steady income

• Higher short-term pay

Understanding your priorities is the first step in deciding which type of role is right for you. Whether you’re looking at engineering jobs or civil construction jobs, these priorities will shape your choice

As an employer, your priorities may be slightly different:

• Do you need long-term staff you can train and promote internally?

• Or do you need specialist expertise for a short-term project?

• Is it more important to control overheads or to secure in-house capability?

Knowing your business priorities will help you decide whether a permanent hire or a contractor will deliver the best value.

When it comes to job security, a permanent role generally feels safer. Even if projects slow down, you’re still on the payroll, and benefits like redundancy pay or notice periods may apply. With a contract job, your income is tied to the life of the project. That said, many contractors reduce this risk by building strong reputations and networks, or by working with specialist built environment and infrastructure recruitment agencies that can connect them to new opportunities as contracts come to an end.

Permanent hires give you stability and allow you to develop internal capability over the long term. However, contractors provide flexibility - you can scale your workforce up or down depending on project demand. Employers who rely solely on permanent staff may struggle during peaks, while those who use contractors too heavily may face gaps in knowledge retention. The right balance often depends on your pipeline of projects.

Contract roles are attractive if you value flexibility. You can choose projects, set availability boundaries, and build in breaks for travel, family, or personal goals.

Permanent roles are better suited if you want structured career progression. In the civil construction and engineering sector, permanent employees are often given access to structured training, mentorship, and promotion pathways, as many consultancies prefer to develop talent internally.

Contractors deliver immediate expertise but may not stay long enough to justify investment in training. Permanent staff, however, are worth developing as they bring continuity, adopt company culture, and are more likely to grow into leadership positions.

Contract roles in engineering demand specialist expertise from day one, sharpening your depth of knowledge in specific areas. Permanent jobs, by contrast, expose you to a wider mix of responsibilities. Employers are also more likely to fund professional development, certifications, and mentorship for permanent staff.

So, ask yourself: Do you want to deepen your expertise in one niche, or broaden your skills across multiple areas?

Hiring contractors gives you immediate access to highly skilled professionals who already have specialist knowledge. But if your goal is to build a pipeline of leaders, investing in permanent hires gives you the chance to shape their growth, train them in-house, and retain knowledge over time. If building long-term leadership is your priority, permanent hires may be the better fit. Learn how to set them up for success in our blog on onboarding new employees.